A competency-based interview asks you to prove each skill in the job description with a real example from your past. Every question starts with something like "Tell me about a time when...", and the panel scores your answer against a fixed list of what good looks like.
That rigid format is there for a reason. In a 2022 re-analysis of decades of hiring research, Paul Sackett and colleagues found structured interviews "had the highest mean operational validity" of any selection method, at .42. Cognitive ability tests, long the textbook winner, came in at .31.
So the panel isn't being stiff for fun. They trust the script more than their gut. You win it with true stories, told in order, where your own actions fill most of the time.
It's a structured interview built around the person specification. The employer picks a handful of competencies, writes a question for each, and asks every candidate the same ones. Prospects says they're "also known as structured, behavioural or situational interviews."
The idea underneath is simple. The London School of Economics' guide for its hiring managers (January 2019) says the method assumes "past behaviour is the best predictor for future behaviour." It suggests competency questions make up "around 70%" of the interview, with the other 30% on technical skills. So expect most of your hour to be stories.
Have one true story ready for each, from the last three years if you can.
| Competency | Question | What they're listening for |
|---|---|---|
| Teamwork | Tell me about a time you worked with others to hit a shared goal. What was your part? | Your role, not the team's |
| Communication | Give an example of when you changed how you explained something for your audience. | The change you made and why |
| Problem solving | Tell me about a problem that came up when your manager wasn't around. | How you weighed options before acting |
| Decision making | Describe a decision you made without all the information you wanted. | The risk you named and how you managed it |
| Leadership | Give an example of when you took the lead without being asked. | What made people follow you |
| Conflict | Tell me about a disagreement with a colleague. How did it end? | Calm, fair, and still working together after |
| Planning | Describe a time you juggled competing deadlines. | How you prioritised, and the method |
| Resilience | Tell me about a setback at work and what you did next. | Recovery, with no blaming |
| Adaptability | Give an example of when plans changed at short notice. | Speed, and what you dropped |
| Customer focus | Tell me about a time you went out of your way for a customer. | The extra step and its effect |
| Initiative | Describe something you improved without being told to. | Before and after, with a number |
| Learning | Tell me about feedback that changed how you work. | You acted on it, and it stuck |
Expect probes after each one, like "What would you do differently?" or "What was your part, exactly?" They're checking the story is yours, so pick examples you remember in detail.
Now say each answer out loud and time it, aiming for about two minutes. A story that reads well on paper usually runs long when spoken, with a minute of setup and a rushed ending. Listen for where you say "we". Each one is a point the panel can't give you.
Rehearse your competency stories out loud before a panel hears them, and time every one. UnchartedCareer runs full mock interviews by voice and gives you a scored report on every answer, so you know exactly what to fix. Sign up and run your first mock interview today, so your best story isn't also your first try.
Want to look around first? See how UnchartedCareer works.
Each panel member has a sheet. For every competency there's a list of positive indicators, what a strong answer shows, and often negative ones. For teamwork, a positive might be "asks for others' views". A negative might be "takes credit for the team's work".
You get a separate score per competency, so a brilliant teamwork story can't rescue a thin answer on decision making.
Public bodies often publish their scales. Civil Service departments score each behaviour from 1 to 7. Scotland's Crown Office, for one, sets 4 as its pass mark, and our Civil Service behaviours guide shows the full scale. NHS panels add probes about what you learned, as our NHS interview questions guide explains.
The panel can only score what you say out loud. A story full of "we" gives them nothing to tick.
STAR stands for situation, task, action, result. Prospects teaches STARR, adding reflection: what you learned. Use the extra R in the UK public sector, where panels often probe for it.
A good split for a two-minute answer:
Here's the action part of a weak answer and a strong one, for "Tell me about a time you dealt with an unhappy customer."
Weak: "We looked into it and sorted it out, and they were happy in the end."
Strong: "I rang her back within the hour rather than emailing, because two emails had gone unanswered. I read her the order history so she knew I'd looked. Then I offered a replacement by Friday and set a reminder to check it shipped."
Same story. The second gives the assessor three things to tick.
Three habits cost people marks even with good stories:
A strengths-based interview asks what you enjoy and do well, not what you've done. "What energises you at work?" "Do you prefer starting tasks or finishing them?"
UK graduate recruiters pushed this shift. In August 2015, EY dropped its 2:1 degree requirement for graduate jobs and leaned on online strength assessments. Its research on over 400 graduates found no evidence that university success predicted later success in professional exams.
So prepare differently. Competency answers reward rehearsed stories. Strength answers reward quick, honest ones, so don't script them. Many panels now mix both.
Usually the handful named in the person specification. Count the skills listed there and prepare one story for each, plus a spare.
Yes. Volunteering, study, sport or caring for a relative all count if the example shows the skill clearly and you can say what you personally did.
Competency questions ask what you did. Situational ones ask what you would do, such as "A colleague misses a deadline that affects you. What do you do?" Answer in the same order, in the future tense. Then add a line on when you handled something similar, because a real example makes the plan believable.
Often, yes. Many panels read the competency name before the question, and the person specification lists them in the same words. If they don't, listen for the noun in the question (team, decision, deadline) and answer that one, not the story you'd rather tell.
Tonight, pick the competency you'd least like to be asked about and tell that story out loud, timed. If you hear yourself say "we" more than twice, start again.
Practice the hard questions now, so the real ones feel easy.
Try it outThe 12 internship interview questions students get most, how to answer with class projects, clubs and part-time jobs, what to ask, and a 3-day plan.
Cluely alternatives come in two kinds: live copilots with the same bans and detection risk, and practice tools that make a hidden script unnecessary.
HR interview questions for HR roles, grouped by what they test, the complaint that most often becomes a federal charge, and frames to rehearse out loud.